Inconsistent GUI programming of Visual Studio

    The Visual C++ 6.0 has existed for long time compared to unfortunate Visual Studio .NET 2003. The 2000 versin changed a lot in respect to GUI and it introduced .NET. The 2005 version was somewhat stabilized, and 2008 version looks to continue its tendency.

    With this Visual Studio products, there are some problems. They are :

  1. GUI was changed too much.
  2. Approach in respect to GUI programming is not consistent

    The GUI was changed too much. Visual C++ 6.0 provided easy approach for dynamic data exchange on its class view dialog box. You could select what messages would be handled by a selected class on the same dialog box.

    2003 version was changed a lot, so adoption rate was not good.
From 2005 version, things were streamlined well. However there are still lots of difference.

    For example, does the 2005/2008 version provide a way to set up window message handler? It is pretty difficult to find it.
But here it is.


After selecting a class, open its property pane. Then you can find where you can set up message handlers.

    Second, the way to add / modify event handler is different.
At least adding one is same.


    However, to browse existing event handler, you cannot double click a button. As far as I remember, Visual C++ 6.0 allowed it, existing event handler was opened.
Also, most importantly, the way to add message handler and event handler are very different. Why classes like dialog is in resource file to be represented visually and thus provides a way to add event handler by clicking, while those for views are not visually represented in resource file and its message handler can’t be added/modified by clicking?
This is very important inconsistency.

    So, for .NET, MS introduced “form” programming, whcih is property programming. With property programming paradigm, setting properties, or class member variable, is enough to set up things, e.g. fonts, etc. Also, view classes in .NET framework are also visualized in its resource file.
This was originally pushed by Borland. As far as I know, MS hired a Borland programmer to implement “form programming” paradigm for Visual Studio.

    Because this difference, it is confusing to prepare code with VS from time to time. However, thanks to .NET framework, programming for Windows feels similar to that for Mac nowadays. For last two years, I tried .NET programming. It was quite easy to learn it and found out that .NET classes and its approach is very similar to that of Cocoa/Objective-C.
So, I decided that I could easily start writing in .NET. So, I kept focusing on MFC.

    By the way, I couldn’t decide whether to post this to my Hot Potato blog or here, but this is more about development. So I decided to post it here.


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: